DAILY FROM: AHMEDABAD, CHANDIGARH, DELHI, JAIPUR, KOLKATA, LUCKNOW, MUMBAI, NAGPUR, PUNE, VADODARA JOURNALISM OF COURAGE MONDAY, AUGUST 19, 2024, AHMEDABAD, LATE CITY, 14 PAGES BUSINESS AS USUAL BY UNNY `5.00 WWW.INDIANEXPRESS.COM SINCE 1932 TAKES SUO MOTU COGNIZANCE, DAYS AFTER HC SENDS CASE TO CBI SC steps in, lists Kolkata rape-murder, ‘related issues’ for hearing tomorrow Matter listed before 3-judge bench presided by CJI D Y Chandrachud ANANTHAKRISHNAN G 70PADMAAWARDEE DOCTORSWRITETOPM DAYS AFTER the Calcutta High Court, expressing displeasure over the handling of the case relating to the alleged rape and murder of a junior doctor at the R G Kar Medical College in Kolkata, transferred the probe to the CBI, the Supreme Court has taken suo motu cognizance of the August 9 incident. A three-judge bench presided by Chief Justice of India D Y Chandrachud will hear the matter Tuesday. The bench also comprises Justices J B Pardiwala and Manoj Misra. Thesupplementarycauselist of the Supreme Court for August 20shows“inre:allegedrapeand murderincidentof atraineedoctor in R.G.Kar Medical College andHospital,Kolkataandrelated issues” listed for hearing before the bench, indicating that the court may also look into the acts of vandalismbyamobatthehospital on the night of August 14. On August 13, the High Court division bench of Chief Justice T S Sivagnanam and Justice 70PADMAawardee doctorswrotetoPM NarendraModiSunday, askinghimtopersonally intervenetoaddressthe “alarmingsituation” amidsttheprotestby doctorsacrossthecountry. Theyalsosoughtaspecial lawforprotectionof healthcareworkers. P4 NEW DELHI, AUGUST 18 ‘Data-centric decision-making is a must but caste data is tricky to capture’ JAYANT CHAUDHARY RLD LEADER AND UNION MINISTER PAGE 9 EXPLAINED POLICY LATERALENTRYIN BUREAUCRACY P10 188 HINDU REFUGEES GIVEN CITIZENSHIP INSIDE JMM crisis: Champai says was humiliated, Cracks in TMC: Its MP asks CBI to weighing options; question top cop, gets police notice Hemant targets BJP Supporters of rivalfootball clubsEastBengaland MohunBaganataprotest inKolkata. Partha Paul DURAND CUP MATCH CANCELLED OVER SECURITY ISSUES GIRL RAPED ON BUS IN DEHRADUN, FIVE RAVIK BHATTACHARYA ARRESTED PAGE 4 KOLKATA, AUGUST 18 Hiranmay Bhattacharyya, while expressing displeasure over the handling of the case and observing that “there appears to be no CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 REFLECTING THE unease and an apparent divide within the ruling TMC in West Bengal over the handling of the case of the rape and murder of a junior doctor at the R G Kar Medical College and TMC MP Sukhendu Shekhar Roy Hospital, party seniorleaderand Rajya Sabha MP Sukhendu Shekhar Roy urged the CBI Sunday to conduct custodial interrogation of Kolkata Police Commissioner Vineet Goyal and the college’s former principal SandipGhosh.Withinhours,the Kolkata police issued a notice to Roy, asking him to appear at the police headquarters in Lalbazar. CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 Judiciary to police, institutions have to be rebuilt: Student leader now in interim govt Shah: CAA doesn’t take away citizenship, Cong-led previous govts let ‘intruders’ in Govts come and go, India needs to maintain ties with our people: Nahid Islam EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE SHUBHAJIT ROY THE CONGRESS-LED governments of the past indulged in politics of appeasement by not granting citizenship to refugees fromneighbouringcountriesbut allowed "intruders" into India, UnionHomeMinisterAmitShah said while awarding citizenship to 188 Hindu refugees from Pakistan under the Citizenship (Amendment) Act (CAA) in Ahmedabad Sunday. Hailing CAA as an act of givingrightstolakhsof refugeesliving in India and not to take away citizenship of the minorities, he added that laws are for the people and not the vice-versa. “On theonehand,youallowedintrusion from the borders, you let crores of intruders enter and get citizenshipillegally.Ontheother hand, you told those who follow law, who gave you application (to get citizenship) that there is nosuchscopeinthelaw.Thelaw is for the people, people are not UNDERLINING THAT rebuilding the country is a “big responsibility”andrebuildingtrustintheinstitutions is also a “difficult responsibility”, student leader NahidIslam,whoistheinformation and communications tech advisorintheinterimBangladesh government, has said they are workingonaplanfor“holisticreform” of national institutions — judiciary, police, civilian bureaucracy among others. Thisisthestrongestsignalyet from the Army-backed interim SCHOOLS, COLLEGES REOPEN AFTER A MONTH PAGE 11 DHAKA, AUGUST 18 Union Minister Amit Shah hands over the citizenship certificate to a beneficiary in Ahmedabad Sunday. Chief Minister Bhupendra Patel is also seen. PTI for the law,” he said. “In the past, those who took refugeinIndiabetween1947and 2014werenotgiventhisright(citizenship)andjusticewasnotdone by the governments led by the Congress and its allies owing to the policy of appeasement. They were persecuted in the neighbouring countries because they wereHindu,Jain,BuddhistorSikh, but their persecution continued CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 THE WORLD BLINKEN IN ISRAEL TO PUSH GAZA CEASEFIRE DEAL PAK: EX-ISI CHIEF WAS PART OF IMRAN’S PLOT PAGE 11 Shubhajit Roy Islam: ‘Bangabandhu statues had become symbols of fascism’ government on revisiting the institutions packed with loyalists of Sheikh Hasina whose long rule as Prime Minister came to an end on August 5 when she fled to India. In an interview to The Indian Express,26-year-oldNahidIslam, who spearheaded the quota reforms movement that led to Hasina’s ouster, said, “We haven’t been able to celebrate the victory and the downfall of the Hasina government. It’s abig responsibility for us now.” Islam,who studiedsociology Despite red flags, ministry reimposed solar module list of domestic players YOUR RIGHT TO KNOW E AN XPRESS RTI APPLICATION AGGAM WALIA NEW DELHI, AUGUST 18 DESPITE CONCERNS flagged at the highest levels in the governmentovermarketconcentration inIndia’ssolarPVmoduleindustry and its potential to inflate E E X P L A I NE D AHMEDABAD, AUGUST 18 THE WORLD EXPRESS INDHAKA Rising cost ● difference DOMESTIC solar modules are now 90% more expensive than imports, with prices reaching 18 cents per watt in June compared to 9.1 cents for imported modules. This gap has widened since FY22, when domestic prices were 6% higher than imports. household electricity tariffs, the Ministry of New and Renewable Energy reimposed its mandate requiringsolarprojectstosource modules exclusively from a government-approvedlistofdomesticmanufacturersstartingApril1. Prior to the reimposition of the Approved List of Models and Manufacturers (ALMM) order, former Union Minister of Power andNew and RenewableEnergy R K Singh and the central public sector enterprise SJVN Ltd had explicitly flagged concerns arounddomesticmanufacturers CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 at Dhaka University, is one of the most articulate student leaders. Following Hasina’s departure, it was Islam who announced that NobellaureateProf Muhammad Yunus would head the interim government. He said during Hasina’s rule, institutional structures in the country had been “destroyed” due to “injustice and loot”. “So, we have to reform them, andhavetorebuildtrustinthose institutions… This is a difficult responsibility for us, and we are CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 EXPRESS NETWORK His senior leader in Delhi, CM: ‘Money such a thing that it doesn’t take long’ ABHISHEK ANGAD RANCHI, AUGUST 18 THE JMM-LED ruling alliance in Jharkhand was grappling with a crisis Sunday after JMM senior leaderandformerChief Minister Champai Soren, who reached Delhi amid speculation that he wasreadytocrossovertotheBJP, saidhehadbeen“humiliated”by the JMM and was now left with three options — to retire, start a new party, or join another party. His remarks drew a sharp response from Chief Minister Hemant Soren who accused the BJP of “poaching MLAs” and “dividing society”. The PTI news agency quoted him saying in a Godda function that “money is such a thing that it doesn't take long for politicians to move here and there”. HemantSoren,whoreturned to the post in July after being granted bailin an allegedmoney launderingcase(ChampaiSoren had to step down as CM), claimedthattheBJPhadbrought people from Gujarat, Assam and Maharashtra to “spread poison among the tribals, Dalits, backward classes and minorities and make them fight with each other”, the PTI reported. He was quoted saying: “Forget about so- NEW DELHI, AUGUST 18 PAGES 2, 5 EXPRESS NETWORK AS BJP WORKERS TARGET AJIT CONVOY, NCP ASKS FADNAVIS TO CLARIFY PAGE 2 ciety,thesepeopleworktobreak families and parties. They poach MLAs.” Champai Soren, in a post on X, claimed that on July 3, he was told that all his scheduled programmes were cancelled Inastatement,hesaidhehad no one in the party to go to with his problems as the JMM’s central executive meeting had not been held for years. “I am counted among the CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 AI stewardess assaulted by intruder in hotel room near Heathrow EXPRESS NEWS SERVICE COAST GUARD DG RAKESH PAL DIES OF CARDIAC ARREST IN CHENNAI ‘ANTI NATIONAL’: RAHUL ATTACKS LATERAL ENTRY IN GOVT TOP JOBS Former Jharkhand CM Champai Soren at the Delhi airport on Sunday. PTI AN AIR India air hostess staying inahotelnearLondonHeathrow airport was assaulted by an intruder who entered her room late at night, according to sources. The incident took place earlier this week. The air hostess, who sustained injuries, was rescued by those in adjacent rooms and hotel staff who responded to her cries for help, and the intruder was nabbed. The airline confirmed the incident, but did not elaborate on thenatureof assaultandinjuries sustained by the air hostess. The matter is being investigated by London police and Air India is working with it to “pursue the mattertothefullestextentof the law”, the airline said. “Air India accords foremost priority to the safety, security and well-being of our crew and staff members. We are deeply anguished by an unlawful incident of intrusion at a hotel, operated by a major international chain, that affected one of our crew members,” an Air India spokesperson said. “We are providing all possible support to our colleague and their broader team, including CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 A derelict school still running — just to keep 7 kids from dropping out PAGE 1 ANCHOR AISWARYA RAJ GURUGRAM, AUGUST 18 BEHIND THE iron gate lies a derelict building overrun by knee-high vegetation. Without even a board to announce its name, the only signs of life at Gurugram's Government Primary School Gopalpur Khera are its seven students who troop pastitsfadedtricolourgateseach day, besides their sole teacher. Despitenotfulfillingthemin- imum enrollment criteria of 20 students,thisprimaryschool,locatedaround 1km fromDwarka Expressway, has not been shut and continues to be a lifeline for its little learners. Past the unkempt front yard with brown plastic chairs, seepagestains mar theroof andwalls of the school. Barring one, its three other classrooms are locked. A peek inside the only open classroom reveals a sad state of affairs: there’s broken furniture, some kitchen utensils, a lawn mower, a carrom board, trunks and a chunky television. Theschool’sonlytwotoiletsfor studentsarefilthyandthekitchen partially damaged. The midday meal is cooked and served by an agencyhiredbytheHaryanagovernment.LocatedundertheGarhi Harsaru cluster in the Municipal Corporation of Manesar area, the GopalpurKheraschoolwasestablishedin1985.Localssayitfellinto a stateof neglectoverthelast few yearsafterthetransferofoneofits twoteachers. Sitting cross-legged on a dusty red-black mat in the verandah, his back towards the blackboard with triple-digit Maths problems scrawled all over,Divesh,11,astudentof Class 5,isreadinghisEnglishtextbook. Children of migrant labourers The verandah of the Govt Primary School in Gurugram’s Gopalpur Khera functions as a ‘classroom’. Aiswarya Raj from BiharandUttar Pradesh, all seven students are forced to study in the school’s verandah duetothelackof anactivepower connection. Despite moving to Gurugram and this school from Uttar Pradesh’s Kannauj just a year ago with his migrant parents, Divesh is the only student who wears a uniform, can multiply and divide three-digit numbers, and also read sentences in English. Sitting next to him, besides his five other schoolmates, is a shy six-yearold staring at his textbook. With the school’s lone tutor — Lalita Chawla, a guest teacher who joined in July on a 45-day contract — on leave, substitute teacher Anil Kumar from the nearestprimaryschool,around2 km away, is covering for her. Using one hand to swat the flies or brush off the ants swarming the “classroom”, the children sit withtheirbooksintheother.The teacher sits away from them, making himself available when the need arises. Divesh tells The Indian Express, “Earlier, two classrooms were open and we would sit there. There were more children in school then. Now, since there is no power, we can’t sit inside.” Though the student register for the current academic year is missing,onefromlastyearshows that over 25 children studied in the school till March 2024. In 2011, the Haryana government had said it would undertake a rationalisation exercise at primary and upper primary schools before each academic yeartodecideonappropriateaction—mergeorcloseschoolsdepending on enrollment. An Education Department official told The Indian Express that government schools are required to have at least two teachers even if the strength is just 25 children. Accordingtoanannualreporton CONTINUED ON PAGE 2 Ahmedabad